Indiana nursing homes › Plymouth › Pilgrim Manor
Pilgrim Manor
222 Parkview St, Plymouth, IN 46563 · Marshall County · (574) 936-9943
Fewer inspection deficiencies (14) than 9% of nursing homes in Indiana. Rated #2 of 2 nursing homes in Plymouth by overall CMS stars. Nursing hours per resident day: 3.4 — below the Indiana average of 3.69.
Quality details (CMS data, Oct 2026 release)
| Certified beds | 78 |
| Average residents per day | 64.7 |
| Ownership | Government |
| Participation | Medicare and Medicaid |
| Nursing hours per resident per day | 3.43 (Indiana average: 3.69) |
| — of which RN hours | 0.62 |
| — of which nurse aide hours | 2.29 |
| Staff turnover | 39% |
| RN turnover | 43% |
| Most recent health inspection | Feb 13, 2026 |
| Deficiencies cited (latest cycle) | 14 (Indiana average: 7.2) |
| Weighted inspection score (lower is better) | 109.5 |
| Federal fines in past 3 years | 1 fine(s) totaling $45,580 |
| Payment denials / penalties | 1 |
Compare homes before you choose
Ratings change with every inspection cycle. Compare Pilgrim Manor side by side with other homes in Plymouth and check the latest red flags:
See all nursing homes in Plymouth →Top-rated nursing homes in Indiana
Plan the cost of care in Indiana
What does care cost in Indiana? A semi-private nursing home room runs a median of $8,943 per month — see Indiana senior care cost medians and check Indiana Medicaid eligibility limits.
Source: U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), Provider Information dataset, Oct 2026 release (processing date Sep 1, 2026). Ratings reflect inspection cycles and reported staffing; visit any facility in person before deciding.